As the season of gratitude approaches, thoughts of elaborate family meals and time-consuming cooking can become overwhelming. Fortunately for New Yorkers, dining out or ordering takeout has become a beloved tradition, especially on Thanksgiving. Many local restaurants are stepping up to the plate, offering mindfully crafted, chef-prepared meals. Instead of stressing over the stove or hauling out the oven racks, you can sit back, relax in your most comfortable attire, and enjoy quality food without the hassle of cooking. Here, we explore some of the top options for Thanksgiving takeout in New York City, ideal for those who prefer convenience and indulgence on this festive holiday.
For those yearning for a traditional Thanksgiving with an Italian flair, L’antica Pizzeria da Michele is the place to be. Their West Village location offers a holiday prix fixe menu from November 22 to November 28. For $65 per person, dine-in guests can savor dishes like roasted turkey or whole chicken accompanied by a bounty of classic Italian side dishes, including lasagna bolognese and creamy pumpkin soup. Alternatively, their takeout bundle, priced at $200, serves four and is designed to provide a delicious feast at home, complete with dessert options like pecan or pumpkin pie. It’s a fantastic way to merge the holiday spirit with a touch of Italian heritage.
If you’re planning a large family gathering, Carmine’s—a staple in Italian-American dining—offers its renowned Thanksgiving feast available for delivery or pickup for $395. Catering to six to eight people, the feast features a 16- to 18-pound roast turkey and eight beloved sides, including homemade cranberry sauce and sweet potatoes topped with marshmallows and maple syrup. For $30 extra, you can add an apple or pumpkin pie to round out the meal, making it a perfect option for those wanting to enjoy the comforts of home without the culinary stress.
For gastronomes looking to indulge in a luxurious experience, the Aquavit Thanksgiving To-Go package may be the answer. Priced at $595 and serving four, this exquisite meal features fennel and caraway spiced turkey breast along with a smoked turkey leg confit. Side options include roasted squash and Brussels sprouts, alongside a rich pumpkin pie. Orders must be placed in advance, showcasing not just the culinary prowess of a Michelin-starred kitchen, but also the anticipation that comes with such a lavish holiday offering.
For those who lean towards comfort food with a twist, Prospect Heights’ Alta Calidad provides a unique take on the Thanksgiving feast. Their menu, priced at $100, includes a Mexican-inspired BBQ sauce-glazed turkey breast complemented by an array of festive sides like spicy root vegetable stuffing and grilled Mexican spoonbread. This option introduces vibrant flavors and a creative take on the traditional holiday meal, catering not just to your appetite but also your spirit of adventure.
Zaab Zaab, known for its Isaan Thai delicacies, offers something unexpected: a Thai-infused Thanksgiving menu. Priced at $160, this feast boasts a rotisserie roasted heirloom turkey that is marinated in flavorful herbs, served with an assortment of sides highlighting authentic Thai culinary traditions. The opportunity to combine Thanksgiving with global flavors not only spices up the holiday but reflects the multicultural fabric of New York City.
For a more laid-back affair, Poppy’s café in Brooklyn serves up an array of quick-to-sell-out Thanksgiving spreads, offering both delivery and pickup. Guests can select from a variety of á la carte dishes that include seasonal favorites and decadent desserts. Their menu highlights local and seasonal produce, encapsulating the warm, inviting atmosphere synonymous with shared meals during the holiday season.
As Thanksgiving approaches, the dining options in New York City provide diverse avenues for celebrating this cherished holiday. From traditional feasts to inventive international takes, the city offers something for everyone. Whether you opt for a fine-dining experience or a cozy meal at home, remember that the importance of Thanksgiving lies not only in the food but also in the joy of connection. So, grab your sweatpants, order from your favorite local restaurant, and enjoy the holiday in the most stress-free way possible—giving yourself ample reasons to be grateful this season.